Which Magic Puzzle Company Jigsaw Puzzle Should You Buy in 2025?

If you're a puzzle enthusiast looking for a unique and engaging experience, The Magic Puzzle Company offers a range of jigsaw puzzles that truly stand out. These puzzles not only challenge you with their intricate designs but also immerse you in a storytelling journey, culminating in a surprise ending that adds a delightful twist to the puzzling process. This innovative approach makes Magic Puzzles a must-have for any avid puzzler. But which one should you start with? Let's explore some of the best options from their collection.

TL;DR: These are the best Magic Puzzle Company puzzles

Our Top Pick

The Mystic Maze • Series One

6$22.97 at Amazon

The Sunny City • Series One

4$22.99 at Amazon

The Happy Isles • Series One

7$22.97 at Amazon

The Crystal Caves • Series Two

3$24.12 at Amazon

The Forest Feast • Series Two

3$24.12 at Amazon

The Busy Bistro • Series Two

2$22.97 at Amazon

The Gnomes' Homes • Series Three

2$22.99 at Amazon

The Magic Puzzle Company offers a diverse selection of puzzles, each with unique original artwork and a compelling story. Here are some of our top picks from their series, providing insight into their special surprise endings. We'll alert you to spoilers before revealing what happens, so you can decide whether to peek or keep the mystery intact.

The Mystic Maze

Our Top Pick

The Mystic Maze • Series One

6$22.97 at Amazon

Part of Series One, the 1,000-piece Mystic Maze puzzle features enchanting artwork by Boya Sun. It follows a character in a yellow outfit navigating an enchanted maze to find a lost friend. The puzzle's design is rich with mystical tones of soft purples and blues. Curious about the ending? Here's what happens:

The Mystic Maze Secret Ending:

Show Spoilers The character in yellow finds their lost friend.

The Sunny City

The Sunny City • Series One

4$22.99 at Amazon

Another 1,000-piece puzzle from Series One, The Sunny City showcases vibrant artwork by Felicia Chiao. The puzzle depicts a bustling city scene in bright oranges and yellows, hiding a "sunny secret." Here's the surprise at the end:

The Sunny City Ending:

Show Spoilers Big flowers are blooming in the center of the city.

The Happy Isles

The Happy Isles • Series One

7$22.97 at Amazon

Completing Series One, The Happy Isles is a 1,000-piece puzzle with art by Sarah Becan. This puzzle brings to life colorful island paradises, revealing an unexpected fate for its inhabitants. Here's what you'll discover at the end:

The Happy Isles Secret Ending:

Show Spoilers A sea monster has been causing trouble in The Happy Isles.

The Crystal Caves

The Crystal Caves • Series Two

3$24.12 at Amazon

Moving to Series Two, The Crystal Caves is a 1,000-piece puzzle with artwork by Odsanyu. It tells a story of an ancient rivalry between crystals and mushrooms. Here's the outcome of their conflict:

The Crystal Caves Secret Ending:

Show Spoilers A triangular area forms within the cave that shows the crystals and mushrooms as friends.

The Forest Feast

The Forest Feast • Series Two

3$24.12 at Amazon

Also from Series Two, The Forest Feast features art by Sanne-Marie Kohlmann. This puzzle promises to reveal the inspiration behind a grand feast. Here's what you'll find at the center:

The Forest Feast Secret Ending:

Show Spoilers There's a giant burger, fries, and drink at the center of the puzzle.

The Busy Bistro

The Busy Bistro • Series Two

2$22.97 at Amazon

Rounding out Series Two, The Busy Bistro is a 1,000-piece puzzle with artwork by Oscar Sun. It showcases a bustling scene with busy rats, but what's the reason for their hustle? Here's the surprise ending:

The Busy Bistro Secret Ending:

Show Spoilers There's a big cat that's eating all the food.

The Gnomes' Homes

The Gnomes' Homes • Series Three

2$22.99 at Amazon

From Series Three, The Gnomes' Homes is a 1,000-piece puzzle with artwork by Ninn Salaün. It tells a charming story of gnomes and their habitat, but a twist awaits at the end. Here's what happens:

The Gnomes' Homes Secret Ending:

Show Spoilers A large tree spirit shows up to protect the gnomes' homes from the construction work.

What Makes The Magic Puzzle Company a Good Brand?

The Magic Puzzle Company stands out due to its innovative approach to puzzles. Each puzzle contains over 50 easter eggs and a special ending, creating a unique and engaging experience. The company's mission, as stated on their website, is to blend traditional jigsaw puzzles with elements from tabletop games and magic, resulting in highly entertaining puzzles. Their successful Kickstarter campaign, which garnered 62,284 backers, is a testament to the strong support and belief in their vision.

Additionally, Magic Puzzles are designed to be re-packaged and shared, allowing you to pass on the fun to others. After completing your puzzle, you can follow their re-packing guide to share the experience.

We consider The Magic Puzzle Company to be one of the top puzzle brands to buy in 2025. For more recommendations, check out our roundup of the best puzzle brands. If you're interested in more puzzle options, explore our list of the best jigsaw puzzles for adults.